Compare the Best Payroll Services for Small Business of 2025
10 Best Payroll Services for Small Business of 2025
Methodology
We began our testing of the best payroll services for small businesses by collecting data across 41 criteria in six separate categories on 61 payroll software solutions. Each product’s score was then weighted to emphasize the features, value and other factors that are most important for managing a small business’s payroll. I then conducted hands-on testing of the 10 products that we ranked the highest to determine the areas in which each excelled, as well as the type of business the product best serves. No matter what your payroll needs are or what type of business you operate, we’re confident that one of our top picks will be the right fit for your organization.
Decision Factor | Scoring Weight | Description |
---|---|---|
Features | 45% | Among the products’ highest-weighted features are payroll analytics, tax filing and payments, compliance, automated payroll functions and help with onboarding. |
Expert Score | 20% | The overall features (8%) and value (8%) of the payroll service accounted for the bulk of its score in this category, along with its ease of use (4%). |
Consumer Sentiment Index | 15% | This score represents the aggregate ratings of each product in seven separate categories on three popular user review sites. |
Value | 10% | The base monthly price of each payroll service and its annual subscription cost account for its score in this category. |
Service and Support | 8% | Offering live chat, telephone and email support contributed 2% each to the score of each service, as did having a knowledge base for self-support. |
App Store Reviews | 2% | We considered each product’s score on Google Play and Apple’s App Store (0.5% each), along with whether it offered a mobile app at all (1%). |
How To Choose the Best Payroll Service for Small Businesses
The best payroll service for your small business is the one that makes your payroll operations as accurate and efficient as possible while staying within your budget. Apart from price, the factors that have the greatest impact on the payroll service buying decision are meeting your payroll tax obligations, processing payroll runs quickly and simply, timely delivery of pay to employees and contractors, helpful payroll analytics, and easy, secure access to payroll data by managers and workers.
Essential Small Business Payroll Service Features
These are the key features of a winning payroll solution for your small business.
- Automated processes. Automating payroll processes reduces the likelihood of payroll mistakes while also speeding up processing time. Rippling’s custom recipes save companies time and aggravation by limiting manual payroll operations such as creating off-cycle payroll runs for retroactive changes in pay rates.
- Built-in compliance. Payroll tax filing and payments need to be done right the first time to avoid costly penalties. The best payroll services automatically file and pay employee tax withholding and other obligations to ensure your company maintains compliance. The Compliance Assistant built into TriNet’s payroll and HR outsourcing service automatically calculates, files and pays payroll taxes while monitoring overtime rules such as those in the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA).
- Direct deposit. Nothing will sour your relationship with your employees faster than delays in delivering their pay. QuickBooks Payroll, Square Payroll and Gusto’s Plus and Premium plans include next-day direct deposit of pay to workers’ bank accounts. QuickBooks promises same-day delivery when payroll runs are completed by 7 a.m. PT.
- Employee portal. All 10 payroll services in our rankings offer employees access to their payroll data through a secure portal as well as by using a mobile app. However, Paycor’s mobile app shines, as it features a mobile wallet that lets workers access up to 50% of their earned pay up to two days before the scheduled payday.
- Reports and analytics. ADP RUN’s payroll reports go beyond standard payroll reports by covering garnishments, local tax withholding by quarter, benefit deductions and partial or missed deductions.
- Roles and permissions. Ensuring the security of payroll data requires limiting access to managers and employees alike. Justworks gives companies granular control over the information that administrators and managers can access. The company also lets you grant access to outside accountants and other third-party administrators. Rippling automates permissions by building them into profiles that limit view, edit and other actions based on specific roles.
Value
When calculating the cost of a payroll service for your small business, a primary consideration is the expenses you would incur if your payroll wasn’t done right. In addition to the time and effort required to correct mistakes in wages paid to employees and contractors, you have to factor in the penalties and other fees charged by government tax-collecting agencies for failure to comply with tax withholding and other regulations.
Payroll processing is a core business process that impacts nearly all other aspects of your operation, yet it can be a costly mistake for a business to purchase payroll features they don’t need. Look for a payroll service whose products give you the option to start with the basics and add functions as your payroll needs change.
Our pick as the most affordable payroll service for small business is Square Payroll, which packs plenty of high-end features into its single plan priced at $35 a month plus $6 per employee a month. These include unlimited payroll runs, multistate payroll, payroll automation and next-day direct deposit. Another affordable option is Wave Payroll, which costs $40 a month plus $6 per person a month and integrates seamlessly with the company’s free and low-cost accounting software.
Payroll Compliance
Every business bears responsibility for complying with federal, state and local laws related to employee compensation and following other payroll compliance best practices.
Small business payroll software automates many of these compliance requirements such as filing and paying payroll taxes automatically and alerting companies to upcoming compliance deadlines. They also help businesses classify their workers correctly as employees or contractors to avoid being fined for misclassifications, and they provide a record of payroll and employee time and attendance.
Third-Party Payroll Integrations
The most common third-party payroll integrations are employee time and attendance tracking, scheduling, retirement plans and health benefits, recruiting, compensation management and general accounting systems. Many small businesses find it most effective to purchase their payroll and HR support services from the same vendor, such as Gusto or Rippling, both of which sell plans that combine the two functions. Others choose products that integrate payroll with other accounting operations such as QuickBooks Payroll and Wave Payroll.
Retailers and restaurants can improve the efficiency of their payroll processing by going with Square Payroll, which links time, attendance, tips and other data collected by their POS systems to their payroll processes. The payroll services in our rankings that offer the most extensive collections of third-party integrations are Rippling, QuickBooks Payroll and ADP.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
What Is a payroll service?
A payroll service supports a business’s payroll operations by preparing payroll runs for salaried and hourly employees and contractors. It handles payroll tax calculations, filing and payment. It also deducts benefit premiums and other payments taken out of employees’ pay.
Do I need a payroll service for my small business?
Nearly all small businesses benefit by hiring a payroll service because of the added security the companies provide. Many payroll services offer a guarantee that their customers’ payroll will be 100% accurate and that they will comply with all payroll tax, filling, withholding and other regulatory obligations.
Do payroll services provide benefits administration?
Most of the small business payroll services we reviewed combine payroll processing with some level of benefits administration. Vendors such as Gusto and Rippling bundle their payroll and HR services, while others, such as Wave Payroll and Justworks, focus primarily on payroll and offer meager HR functionality.
Do payroll providers also handle taxes and compliance?
All the payroll services in our rankings calculate and file your business’s payroll taxes, and many pay the taxes automatically. The vendors offer varying levels of compliance support, ranging from Wave Payroll’s basic payroll compliance to TriNet’s outsourced payroll compliance services and Compliance Manager that’s bundled with its administrative services organization (ASO).