Erin Patterson mushroom murder case: triple killer faces life sentence in historic live broadcast

Victoria's Supreme Court will sentence triple murderer Erin Patterson on Monday morning, September 8, in a hearing broadcast live for the first time in the state's history. Justice Christopher Beale will deliver Patterson's sentence beginning at 9:30 AM in a proceeding expected to last approximately 30 minutes.

The court has granted permission for a television camera to film inside the courtroom with a 10-second delay, marking an unprecedented move for Victoria's judicial system.

Also read: Erin Patterson found guilty in 'mushroom murder' case that ...

Death cap mushroom murder conviction details

Patterson, 50, was convicted in July following an 11-week trial for murdering Don and Gail Patterson, parents of her estranged husband Simon, and his aunt Heather Wilkinson. The jury also found Patterson guilty of attempting to murder Ian Wilkinson, Heather's husband.

The mushroom murder occurred during a lunch Patterson hosted in July 2023, where she deliberately served beef wellingtons laced with death cap mushrooms to her guests.

Victim impact statements and sentencing arguments

Ian Wilkinson, a pastor and attempted murder victim, delivered a victim impact statement during pre-sentencing hearings last month, offering Patterson forgiveness.

"Now I am no longer Erin Patterson's victim, and she has become the victim of my kindness," he said.

However, Wilkinson stated he was "compelled to seek justice" for the three murder victims and said his prayer for Patterson was that she would use her custody time for reform.

Simon Patterson described how his estranged wife's crimes had deprived their two children, born in 2009 and 2014, of "the kind of relationship with their mother that every child yearns for."

Life sentence debate in mushroom murder case

Both prosecution and defense agreed Patterson should receive a life sentence for what Justice Beale termed "horrendous" crimes. Prosecutors argued for no possibility of parole, while defense counsel requested Patterson be given a chance for eventual release.

Also read: Kathleen Folbigg to receive ex gratia payment after 20 years of wrongful conviction; here’s who else has b

Defense barrister Colin Mandy SC argued Patterson's notoriety resulted in onerous prison conditions, spending 22 hours daily locked in her cell, which should influence Beale's sentencing decision. He contended his client's isolation increased the "burden of imprisonment" compared to other prisoners.

Prosecutor Jane Warren acknowledged the court could consider these conditions during sentencing deliberations.

Prison conditions and legal precedents

Justice Beale noted Patterson's isolation for at least 14 months since her November 2023 arrest "doesn't sound very humane."

Victoria's maximum penalty for murder is life imprisonment without parole. The standard sentence is 25 years' imprisonment, according to the Sentencing Advisory Council of Victoria guide for judicial officers.

The last triple murderer sentenced in Victoria was Robert Farquharson, convicted of murdering his children in 2007 and sentenced to life imprisonment with a minimum 33-year term.

Appeal process and legal defense

Patterson has until October 6 to lodge appeals against her conviction, sentence, or both. She had pleaded not guilty to all charges, claiming the deaths were a tragic accident.

Also read: Michael Slater sentenced to four years in prison for domestic violence, but walks free

The mushroom murder case represents a significant legal precedent for Victoria's court system, both for the severity of the crimes and the historic decision to broadcast sentencing proceedings live.